Quote:
Originally Posted by NotSteve
I'm still waiting for you to prove I'm wrong by doing the example I said above.
|
How can I make this any clearer?
What you said makes no sense whatsoever. I asked you to explain it, but you're simply beating around the bush. Now others are expressing the same confusion, because it simply does not make any sense. But since you are insisting on proof, I will show you how ridiculous a claim it really is:
Let's say you are running a trip I've done countless times: Harrisburg, PA to Lansing, MI. In that trip, you'll run 258 miles in PA, 245 miles in OH, 16 miles in IN, and 84 miles in MI. You'll owe $34.02 in IFTA tax for that one trip.
Now, you have 4 states you can fuel in. Since the entire trip is 603 miles, and you are getting 6 mpg, I will use a 100 gallon fill up, and I will base it off current pump price at Pilot in each state.
PENNSYLVANIA: The current pump price at Pilot in Carlisle, PA is $3.879, and of that, the fuel tax is $0.381, bringing the actual pump price down to $3.498. If you were to put the 100 gallons in there, you would overpay your fuel tax in PA by $21.72. You would overpay the fuel tax on the entire trip by $4.08.
OHIO: The current pump price at Pilot in North Lima, OH is $3.899, and of that, the fuel tax is $0.280, bringing the actual pump price down to $3.619. If you were to put the 100 gallons in there, you would overpay your fuel tax in OH by $16.57. You would UNDERPAY the fuel tax on the entire trip by $6.02.
INDIANA: The current pump price at Pilot in Fremont, IN is $3.999, and of that, the fuel tax is $0.270, bringing the actual pump price down to $3.729. Then, you have the hidden fuel tax in Indiana of $0.11, so your actual pump price is $3.839. If you were to put the 100 gallons in there, you would overpay your fuel tax in IN by $15.28. You would UNDERPAY the fuel tax on the entire trip by $18.02.
MICHIGAN: The current pump price at Pilot in Battle Creek, MI is $3.999, and of that, the fuel tax is $0.392, bringing the actual pump price down to $3.607. If you were to put the 100 gallons in there, you would overpay your fuel tax in MI by $33.71. You would OVERPAY the fuel tax on the entire trip by $5.18.
Therefore, the logical, business minded person would clearly see that fueling in Pennsylvania would be the cheapest place to fuel, because you have a lower pump price (minus the tax), and a higher fuel tax rate.
Now, I'll ask you once again. Pretty please, with fucking sugar on top, stop beating around the bush and explain why what state you fuel in matters less to someone with their own authority than someone operating under someone else's authority, because the calculations above are the same for an independent as they are for someone operating under someone else's authority.
:roll: