Why do trucking companies need recruiters?
#11
Originally Posted by Ridge Runner
Did you stop to think about the fact that MOST large companies have "recruiters". Sometimes they are given a different title but they do the same thing for a different group of people in different settings ( college comes to mind ).
If M.I.T. didn't "recruit" the brightest minds in the country, we wouldn't have half of the techonology we have. "Recruiting" is as old as FREE Enterprise! It's worked well for over 200 years! But, I guess Cluggy has a better way to run the country and the economy! :roll:
__________________
Remember... friends are few and far between. TRUCKIN' AIN'T FOR WUSSES!!! "I am willing to admit that I was wrong." The Rev.
#12
Senior Board Member
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Leander, TX
Posts: 1,266
Originally Posted by Cluggy619
As most of you have pointed out, some of the majors corperations also use recruiters, or "head hunter" But they don't look for mail room clerks, they look for upper management.
And if anyone can tell me what major corperation other that within the driving industry has a 120% and higher turnover rate, I would be glad to concede that recruiters are needed. But lets face facts. If IBM had a 120% turnover rate, they would be out of business. So calling a company successful with that kind of a turnover rate is misquoted. Take away the recruiters, and the company fails. Unable to fill the seats. Am I wrong? Another is Southwest Airlines. They use recruiters for ramp agents and customer service.
#13
Originally Posted by golfhobo
Yeah.... I would HATE to see the demise of football at VA Tech[...]SMALL schools who had to RECRUIT
I have flower beds made from the remains of the Myers house, and the Kirk, and I have several flower beds full of wild plants I rescued from what was to become the new express road to Tech's football stadium. In exchange for these additions, I now have a 20' concrete wall right outside my bedroom window, I have to listen to Jake brakes all night long, and the shooka shooka shooka of light poles swaying in the breeze. I have no night anymore, in the blinding glow of these road lights. I can't see the stars. On top of it all, on game nights, all those @#@#^@ VT flags FLAP FLAP FLAPPING in the wind from the tops of cars sound like gunshots echoing off the concrete walls. All because of Michael Vick, and what a :dung: head that dog butcher turned out to be. Life was a lot better in this little town when Virginia Tech's football team sucked.
#14
Originally Posted by silvan
Originally Posted by golfhobo
Yeah.... I would HATE to see the demise of football at VA Tech[...]SMALL schools who had to RECRUIT
I have flower beds made from the remains of the Myers house, and the Kirk, and I have several flower beds full of wild plants I rescued from what was to become the new express road to Tech's football stadium. In exchange for these additions, I now have a 20' concrete wall right outside my bedroom window, I have to listen to Jake brakes all night long, and the shooka shooka shooka of light poles swaying in the breeze. I have no night anymore, in the blinding glow of these road lights. I can't see the stars. On top of it all, on game nights, all those @#@#^@ VT flags FLAP FLAP FLAPPING in the wind from the tops of cars sound like gunshots echoing off the concrete walls. All because of Michael Vick, and what a :dung: head that dog butcher turned out to be. Life was a lot better in this little town when Virginia Tech's football team sucked. :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: Sounds like a DRIVER needs to go O-T-R for awhile to get some good SLEEP and a view of the COUNTRYSIDE!!! :wink:
__________________
Remember... friends are few and far between. TRUCKIN' AIN'T FOR WUSSES!!! "I am willing to admit that I was wrong." The Rev.
#15
Senior Board Member
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Bella Vista, Arkansas, United States
Posts: 1,408
Originally Posted by continental
Hey, Sheepish,
Thanks for the honest answer. Recruiters create interest where there was none. How do you create interest? By distorting the truth? Giving false information? Everybody knows JB, and there is no interest. Hmmmmm... What do you do? Place ads without identifying the company. We already know that. A bad reputation such as JB's is very hard to live down, and it goes back decades. There must be a reason for that. You would not have the turnover that you have if it was a JOB WORTH KEEPING. That's what I think. How do I create interest, by telling the truth. Not by lying. You seem to think every driver I hire fails over here. In the many years ive been here, I have hired many drivers who are succeeding and still here. I can call them at any time and those drivers will help me close the driver by showing them how great they are doing. I can create interest by having the driver get a calculator out pulling up a JB stock quote on the internet, doing the math and showing them with a small part of their paycheck invested and a few years, they will be making some major money. I can create interest by helping a driver out here on this board that WASNT MY RECRUIT. When he comes back out here and thanks me (see the thread ODE TO SHEEPDANCER) and tells everyone how well hes doing. That creates interest. Not to cut you down dude. But our reputation is fine. We are one of the most respected companies in the nation and the favorite truck driving company of investors and customers. A few angry delusioned drivers who spend their time bashing things on message boards and the CB dont amount to a hill of beans in the real world. You are a very small % of the driving force who makes a lot of noise and really doesnt matter. Hell, there are quite a few of you bashers out here. I dont mind. I even encourage it. Why would I encourage you bashers? Quite simple, you actually help me do my job. You said, everyone has heard of JB and there is no interest. In the last 2 days, I have had 8 drivers on this board contact me about work. Thats way above normal for out here. Why is it happening now? Pretty simple answer. Because cluggy has been on a roll. Giving me a lot of chances to respond. Keeping my name on the top of the threads. How have I responded to his attacks? Ive simply responded with facts,WHICH HAVE IN TURN CREATED INTEREST.
#17
Senior Board Member
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: jackassville (winnipeg, mb)
Posts: 3,280
At my company, although mostly owner/operator, we have zero recruiters. Several people in our HR department will answer questions for you, but your on your own unless your a company driver (mostly teams).
Our fleet is 350 trucks. Penner also doesn't advertise. All word of mouth.
#18
Board Regular
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: NEPA
Posts: 334
Ok, here we go again with the JB Hunt stock.
JB Hunt is a publicly traded company, and you don't have to drive for them to be able to buy their stock, so don't attribute that to DRIVING for JB. And if you think JB is the most respected company out there, you're living in a haze. Come out here on the road and talk to the drivers. The ones you get from this board are the beginners. Most self respecting old hands would not consider your company,DUDE! :? Job hoppers? If recruiters would tell the truth upfront, there would be less "job hoppers". I just love those catch phrases. The companies are just as responsible for that. I had a job offer, where there was supposed to be 90% drop and hook, it turned out to be maybe 10%. Was I a job hopper? Damned right I was. I will not tolerate that crap. Tell me this, Comes In Sheeps Clothes, why is it, that nobody"bashes" Roehl, Boyds Bros., Maverick, etc? And you go on saying that most drivers get fired, and you talk about "job hoppers" and "quitters". Which one is it now? How about some straight talk? You think you can do it? At least Cluggy is constant, and I respect him for that.
__________________
When I get old, I move north and drive slow in the fast lane.
#19
So many answers from angry people. Let me start off by saying I'm not trying to bash recruiters. But we all heard another worker state "My recruiter lied to me, now I'm stuck". Every business that uses them, and of course, the military, all have had workers that said that.
The "recruiter" is nothing more than a sales man. He sells the idea that working for company A is better than working for company B. This is his/hers job. Some tell it like it is, stating what the company has, and what it can do for them. Others embellish on the truth a little, hoping not to get caught until they are paid. And a few just flat out lie. Now, with removing the sales "advertising" that they do by removing them, would the company survive? So far, with all of the answers I have read, you ALL are telling me a resounding NO. Are we all to believe that without them, the company fails? I think not. Companies have a way to adapt, and continue on. Of course, that would mean change, and no-one likes changes. It also means a lower bottom line, because the pay would have to increase a little to out do the competition. Better benefits would have to come out, and generally, a much better working environment for the employee. hmmmmmm, you would think they would want to do this anyways. I think we all can agree that a 120% turnover is simply unacceptable. If I know a company has that kind of a turnover rate, chances are, I won't want to work for them. Now I didn't want to bring any companies into this, so we will make one. Let call the company Paquete, a truck driving company. Now my company has that high turnover rate, 120 %. I also have 15,000 power units, and 14,500 drivers. With a 120% turnover rate, I need to hire 17,400 drivers in the next year to keep the same amount of tractors filled. In 10 years, I would have hired 174,000 drivers. Lets say I have over 100 recruiters, making around 35K per year to keep me with drivers. That's over 3.5 million dollars per year in payroll just to keep the same number of drivers. But what if I give that to the drivers? It comes to 241.38, not even a good Christmas bonus. Now, is my company being managed right? And what should be done to correct the problem, which is keeping my drivers?
__________________
Anyone can learn to drive a truck. Few become truck drivers. 'Deja moo. It's when you feel you have heard this BS before. ![]() ![]() ![]()
#20
Senior Board Member
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Redneckistan
Posts: 2,831
It must be a lovely place in that dreamworld where you live...
We get it already.. you hate JB Hunt and recruiters and practically everything else... The turnover is high because of the job, not recruiters and not the companies. The numbers are the same all over the industry and they aren't changing anytime soon. You better watch that ax your grinding, its about to wear completely away.
__________________
http://agoldstardad.wordpress.com/ |















