Ugly wicked Disaster
#21
Rookie
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Iowa
Posts: 25
Originally Posted by driver67373
Scour is the process by which water begins to erode away the riverbed at the foundation of the piers (the piers are the vertical supports that go from the water up to the bridge). Overtime, the force of the water can erode away enough material that the foundation weakens and becomes lose, if you will. Worst case secenario is that the piers topple over, of course causing the supported structure to collapse. Scouring is a very slow process and is much more difficult to assess and keep track of because since the foundation is under water, in most cases one must ucs a SCUBA diver to check it out. Scour is not much of a problem in slow-flowing streams but tends to occur in steams where the water moves very rapidly and with great force. Given that the Mississippi flows very gently I doubt scour is the culprit in this case. But only time will tell.
Our section of the river from just north of us at Princeton, IL to just south of us, below Muscatine, IA, actually runs East/West, instead of North/South. The reason is because of all the Lock systems along our portion. In '05, the FDOT gave this a passing grade, BUT MnDot gave it a failing grade. The crux of the investigation is going to be on the under-girders; the girders that the surface is laid on. That's where the stress-fatigue was prominently noted in the MNDOT report. The base pillars near both shore lines will be looked at too. The reason for this is that Lock & Dam 1 of the Army Corps of Engineers isn't too far up river from this. It causes a lot of churning and along with the undercurrent, it actually could've caused the scour you mentioned. The Mississippi is like the old duck parable: Calm and peaceful on the top, but paddling and churning like the dickens underneath.
__________________
Some people wouldn't question authority even if it were on the other end of a knock-knock joke.
#22
Senior Board Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 3,589
RockeyMountain:
(Or, anyone Else With Knowledge Pertaining to This!!) I have not really been following the weather on a national scale, but I do know that a number of different parts of the country have experienced torrential rains and very sever flooding. Could flooding have palyed any part in this??
#23
Hearing witness', it fell like a domino effect, which sounds very intentional. The concrete piers look fine, the steel beams appear to have simply folded unto themselves as if someone had taken a torch to a section and cut them. Obviously that wouldn't happen because it would take too long to cut every section so they all fall together.
First things they will look at are the anchor bolts in the piers and the piers themselves to see if they somehow moved at all. The deck resurfacing had nothing to do with this tragedy. A few bolts had to have given way, whether they were helped or not for this to happen.
#24
Board Icon
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 12,859
Originally Posted by Useless
RockeyMountain:
(Or, anyone Else With Knowledge Pertaining to This!!) I have not really been following the weather on a national scale, but I do know that a number of different parts of the country have experienced torrential rains and very sever flooding. Could flooding have palyed any part in this?? t fell like a domino effect, which sounds very intentional. :roll:
__________________
#25
From the surveilance camera video that's out, it looked like the center section (the main span) fell straight down. It didn't look like it buckled whatsoever.
All I know is that I hate bridges even more now. I've never been a fan of any bridge that has any real height to it. I just hope I don't have to cross the New River Gorge bridge on US19 in WV anytime soon.
__________________
My facebook profile: http://www.facebook.com/malaki86
#26
Rookie
Join Date: Nov 2006
Posts: 11
With underground utilities (water, sewer, steam, electric), roads and bridges, flood control management, and other major parts of our country's infrastructure failing at an increasing rate, affecting the lives of thousands of Americans and our very economy, it would be interesting to see how much we have spent rebuilding the infrastructure of Iraq over the past five years, wouldn't it?
__________________
How long will you lie there, you sluggard? When will you get up from your sleep? A little sleep, as little slumber, a little folding of the hands to rest - and poverty will come on you like a bandit and scarcity like an armed man. (Proverbs 6:9-11)
#27
Board Icon
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 2004
Posts: 12,859
Originally Posted by Malaki86
From the surveilance camera video that's out, it looked like the center section (the main span) fell straight down. It didn't look like it buckled whatsoever.
All I know is that I hate bridges even more now. I've never been a fan of any bridge that has any real height to it. I just hope I don't have to cross the New River Gorge bridge on US19 in WV anytime soon. , it would be interesting to see how much we have spent rebuilding the infrastructure of Iraq over the past five years, wouldn't it? :roll: _________________
__________________
#28
Senior Board Member
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 3,589
Originally Posted by yoopr
Originally Posted by Malaki86
All I know is that I hate bridges even more now. I've never been a fan of any bridge that has any real height to it. I just hope I don't have to cross the New River Gorge bridge on US19 in WV anytime soon. You'd LOVE our Mackinac Bridge up here-It used to be the worlds longest Suspension bridge. You're Waaaaaaaay over the water with this one. Useless: Bridges never bothered me; they do bug the hell out of my wife though; just a serious phobia, but she does handle it better than she used to!! Not sure who said this: ....... it would be interesting to see how much we have spent rebuilding the infrastructure of Iraq over the past five years, wouldn't it? Useless: I'm no advocate or fan of the current administration, but speaking as a rather liberal Democrat, I would ask that we focus out attentions upon the tragedy at hand on this thread, the lives that have been lost, and the families, friends, andd loved oned who are hurting and in need of our prayers at this time. Please, there are plenty of other threads to debate politics; this is not one of them. Please, let's keep it that way!! Peace, Useless _________________
#29
I don't think he's trying to stir up something in the politics of the war, but rather focusing on the issue of how much money is being spent on other countries while our own country is starting to literally fall apart (infrastructure).
__________________
My facebook profile: http://www.facebook.com/malaki86
#30
Originally Posted by yoopr
Originally Posted by Malaki86
From the surveilance camera video that's out, it looked like the center section (the main span) fell straight down. It didn't look like it buckled whatsoever.
All I know is that I hate bridges even more now. I've never been a fan of any bridge that has any real height to it. I just hope I don't have to cross the New River Gorge bridge on US19 in WV anytime soon. I can cross them, but I'm not happy about it. At least I'm not at a point that I freeze up or anything.
__________________
My facebook profile: http://www.facebook.com/malaki86 |

